FACEBOOK TWITTER
26/04/2018

IFOAM and FiBL study: Socio-economic impacts of GMOs on European agriculture

IFOAM EU Group recently released a new study on the impacts of GMOs on European agriculture, in partnership with FiBL (Research Institute of Organic Agriculture). Because of the high risk of adventitious presence of GMOs at different steps of the production chain and the consequences, there is a huge effort and high expense for measures to avoid contamination. The study aims at identifying coexistence strategies of non-GM and organic supply chain actors to ensure GMO-free products and estimate the coexistence costs.

Background: Contamination cannot be excluded

Genetically modified (GM) crops (e.g. maize, soybean, oilseed rape and cotton) have been produced commercially since 1996. Official statistics show that in 2016, 185 million hectares of GM crops were grown globally corresponding to 3.4% of the cultivated agricultural area (UAA) worldwide. Compared to Canada or the US, cultivation of GM crops in the EU agriculture is limited and decreased by 4.2% from 136,338 ha UAA in 2016 to 130,571 ha UAA in 2017. Indeed, GM crops are mainly grown in Spain and Portugal. But GMOs – mainly soy bean meal – are massively imported in the European Union, especially for animal feed.

The EU coexistence strategy seeks to ensure the choice of consumers and farmers between conventional, organic and GM crop production, the study notes. But in the same time adventitious presence of GM crops in non-GM crops cannot be excluded and there is even a high risk for contamination. Therefore, suitable measures are needed during cultivation, harvest, transport, storage and processing to ensure coexistence as well as means to keep GMOs out of the production chain.

High risks and unacceptable costs for the organic sector

The study concludes that coexistence in breeding and seed production is unfeasible.
The highest costs related to coexistence are testing and certification costs.
Moreover, the study brings to light the unbearable situation of the organic sector when risks of contamination are too high: Operators are obliged to adapt the production or to abandon certain types of productions. Such a situation is unacceptable.

The organic sector should not bear the costs related to biotechnologies and should be free to produce without GMOs. Therefore, IFOAM EU will continue its advocacy work to raise that concern towards European policy-makers.

The study focusses on four different production chains in five different countries (France (6), Germany, (6), Spain (2), Switzerland (2) and India (1)) and was conducted based on interviews with 17 company representatives from organic and non-organic GMO-free supply chains (seed companies, breeders, feed processors, soy food processors, cotton processors and traders).

The aim of the study is to identify strategies and the corresponding costs of European non-GM and organic supply chain actors to ensure GMO-free commodities and seeds as a consequence of GM crop production in Europe and imports from third countries, as the conductor’s of the study explain. Information received from the interviews was rather qualitative as it is not always possible to quantify and allocate specific costs linked to GMOs. Some strategies are indeed developed to meet different criteria (avoid contamination by pesticides and GMOs). This research was part of IFOAM EU’s ‘Keeping GMOs out of food’ project.

Results from the interviews

As mentioned above, especially the coexistence in breeding and seed production is considered to be unfeasible. A potential GM-contamination case is a tremendous risk to the companies as losing a line means that long-term investment in the breeding for organic agriculture and the profits from the corresponding business are lost. As official testing is perceived to be insufficient by the interviewed companies, additional testing is implemented. The situation is easier in countries with a national GMO ban, because the risk of contamination after import is limited.

Spanish farmers rejected to grow organic maize because of the high risk of contamination by drift from GMOs.

For organic and non-organic GMO-free feed producers, the most important coexistence costs are testing and certification costs. In Spain, due to the high risk of contamination with GMOs, farmers abandoned growing organic maize and thus lost a potential income opportunity. Feed processors fear that a contamination case results in quite relevant costs. The most important avoidance strategies implemented are to source commodities from well-known suppliers or safe origins and operating only organic feed or spatial segregation in specific plants.

The soy food processing companies interviewed, highlighted that costs of coexistence are mainly due to product testing, careful cleaning at every processing stage and certification. Similar to the feed processors, soy food processors also minimise the risk of contamination with GMOs by sourcing organic or non-organic GMO-free soya from well-known suppliers or safe origins.

The coexistence of GM- and non-GM crops results in high costs for GMO-free food producers.

Most of the coexistence costs for the cotton supply chain incur in the production country and during the first stages of cotton processing (delivery and ginning). The most relevant measures to avoid GMO contaminations are access to non-GM seeds, the rejection of contaminated batches and cleaning before each lot is processed.

New GM techniques pose a massive problem for non-GM processors in the food producing industry.

Since the first authorisations of GMOs and first contamination cases, companies seem to have adapted their strategies and to have learnt from past experiences and past contamination cases across Europe. Important strategies adopted by the interviewed companies consist in producing only Identity Preserved (IP) certified products, or in having totally segregated plants.

This suggests that banning the cultivation of GM crops is an efficient strategy and a pre-requisite to maintain coexistence costs to a manageable level. The companies interviewed fear that problems related to GMOs and coexistence costs might increase in the future if the area under GM production grows worldwide.

New genetic engineering techniques are also a growing concern amongst seed companies, and organic and conventional non-GM processors. To allow the GMO-free sector to be able to remain GMO-free, these new techniques need to be regulated within the scope of the GMO legislation and mandatory traceability and labelling is required.

Regulatory framework is needed to develop competitive non-GM businesses

The study showed that coexistence affects the organic and conventional GMO-free sectors in terms of additional costs and in managing insecurity or the permanent prevailing risk of a contamination case respectively.

European non-GM operators are forced to find solutions to minimise this risk by additional testing, limiting sourcing to GMO-free countries and specific suppliers or by even abandoning commodities. Thus, GMO-free business face constraints and lose options for their business.

In line with rising consumption of organic products, the EU should work on a regulatory framework allowing the development of competitive GMO-free businesses.

Following the polluter-pays principle, the costs of coexistence should be born by the companies that place GMOs on the market, and not by the organic and GMO-free sectors.

On the other hand, there is an increasing demand for GMO-free seeds, feed and food and thus, providing GMO-free products is also a business opportunity for European seed companies, farmers and processors.

The adoption of efficient coexistence measures by Member States should be made mandatory at European level and mechanisms to compensate all disadvantages caused by contamination should be established. The unprecedented development of organic agriculture in the European Union is a clear message from European citizens in favour of a more sustainable agriculture, without GMOs. The Commission and the EU Member States should thus provide the regulatory framework that allows developing competitive non-GM businesses.

In order to read the whole study and for further information please visit the IFOAM EU or the FiBL website.

Source and pictures: http://organic-market.info

Share on:
Events & Fairs
13/02/2019

Connature Partner LOHAS expo ready to start!

Connature Partner Lohas and Vegetarian Food Asia will take place at Hong Kong on 22-23/ 2 (Fri to Sat) 10:30 - 19:30 and 24/ 2 (Sun) 11:00 - 20:00 at  Convention Camp; Exhibition  Centre 

05/02/2019

What’s trending in the world of natural & organic beauty for 2019?

Natural Beauty & Spa Show to display over 250 trend-setting beauty brands

28/01/2019

Connature Partner Natural & Organic Products Europe ready to start! Register to attend one of the European Greatest Organic Shows

For over twenty years Natural & Organic Products Europe has been bringing the world’s natural, organic and sustainable businesses together to promote and facilitate trade

15/01/2019

EU organic control in Italy gradually improving

The EU Directorate General for Health and Food Safety inspected Italy's eco-control system in June 2018

09/01/2019

Explore the Best-selling Green Home Products at LOHAS Expo!

Stay tuned, Lohas Expo is coming soon

14/12/2018

Connature Partner Lohas Expo and Vegetarian Food Asia 2019 Hong Kong open registrations

Lohas Expo, Asia's  Leading trade platform  for natural, organic and green lifestyle products will be staged again at 22 - 24 february 2019 at the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre

12/12/2018

Connature Partner Natural & Organic Products Europe 2019, visitor registration opening

Natural & Organic Products Europe 2019 will take place in London on 7-8 april 2019

27/11/2018

Quality buyers pack the aisles at hugely successful Natural Products Scandinavia & Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

4488 attendees from 66 countries at the successful edition of Connature Partners Natural Products Scandinavia & Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

19/11/2018

Winners of 2018 Sustainable Beauty Awards

The winners of the 2018 Sustainable Beauty Awards were announced at a dedicated reception in Paris a few days ago. 

02/11/2018

Organic leaders to reveal the latest trends at Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

Show’s Organic Theatre has confirmed full seminar line-up...

24/09/2018

PFT Conference: European policies, local strategies and future

On the 27th September the European network Pesticide Free Towns invites interested parties to its conference on “European policies, local strategies and future”, which will take place at the European Parliament

14/09/2018

BioBorrel in Amsterdam: Registration open until next week

The newest edition of BioBorrel will be held at Pakhuis de Zwijger in Amsterdam at 6 pm on 26th September 2018

03/09/2018

Bio Fach South East Asia: Successful premiere in Bangkok

In July, BioFach South East Asia at Impact Exhibition Center in Bangkok gathered international stakeholders from the organic sector for the first time

31/08/2018

GO! Organic Festival 8th - 9th september 2018 - London

From artisan breads to vegan wines, from speciality cheeses to organic sauces and soups, from superfood skincare to zero waste soaps – GO! Organic Festival will showcase the sumptuous diversity that lies at the heart of the organic and sustainability movement...

27/08/2018

Biofach China Closing Report

CLOSING REPORT June 2018 of Connature's Partner BioFach China

18/08/2018

Organic Food Iberia 2019: Major new organic trade fair in Madrid

The new trade show Organic Food Iberia will open at the IFEMA exhibition centre in Madrid in 2019.

13/08/2018

Connature Partner, Natural Products Scandinavia & the Nordic Organic Food Fair return to MalmöMässan

Preparations for Natural Products Scandinavia and the Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018 are now well underway, as the Nordic region’s biggest trade shows for natural and organic open its visitor registration for 2018

31/05/2014

Bhutan: Conference on organic and ecological agriculture a full success

From 5 - 8 March 2014, participants from 30 countries gathered in Bhutan at the IFOAM Conference on Organic and Ecological Agriculture in Mountain Ecosystems. The country created the vision of Gross National Happiness and made a visionary commitment to going 100% organic.

01/10/2012

Barcelona, Spain, from 25 to 26 October 2012.: Global Eco Forum 2012

The Euro-Mediterranean forum on sustainability, the Global Eco Forum, will take place in Barcelona, Spain, from 25 to 26 October 2012.

09/07/2012

25 - 29 october - Turin - Salone del Gusto and Terra Madre

For the first time, Salone del Gusto and Terra Madre merge to create a single event that will be held on 25 to 29 October 2012 in Turin, Italy

13/02/2019

Connature Partner LOHAS expo ready to start!

Connature Partner Lohas and Vegetarian Food Asia will take place at Hong Kong on 22-23/ 2 (Fri to Sat) 10:30 - 19:30 and 24/ 2 (Sun) 11:00 - 20:00 at  Convention Camp; Exhibition  Centre 

05/02/2019

What’s trending in the world of natural & organic beauty for 2019?

Natural Beauty & Spa Show to display over 250 trend-setting beauty brands

28/01/2019

Connature Partner Natural & Organic Products Europe ready to start! Register to attend one of the European Greatest Organic Shows

For over twenty years Natural & Organic Products Europe has been bringing the world’s natural, organic and sustainable businesses together to promote and facilitate trade

15/01/2019

EU organic control in Italy gradually improving

The EU Directorate General for Health and Food Safety inspected Italy's eco-control system in June 2018

09/01/2019

Explore the Best-selling Green Home Products at LOHAS Expo!

Stay tuned, Lohas Expo is coming soon

14/12/2018

Connature Partner Lohas Expo and Vegetarian Food Asia 2019 Hong Kong open registrations

Lohas Expo, Asia's  Leading trade platform  for natural, organic and green lifestyle products will be staged again at 22 - 24 february 2019 at the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre

12/12/2018

Connature Partner Natural & Organic Products Europe 2019, visitor registration opening

Natural & Organic Products Europe 2019 will take place in London on 7-8 april 2019

27/11/2018

Quality buyers pack the aisles at hugely successful Natural Products Scandinavia & Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

4488 attendees from 66 countries at the successful edition of Connature Partners Natural Products Scandinavia & Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

19/11/2018

Winners of 2018 Sustainable Beauty Awards

The winners of the 2018 Sustainable Beauty Awards were announced at a dedicated reception in Paris a few days ago. 

02/11/2018

Organic leaders to reveal the latest trends at Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018

Show’s Organic Theatre has confirmed full seminar line-up...

24/09/2018

PFT Conference: European policies, local strategies and future

On the 27th September the European network Pesticide Free Towns invites interested parties to its conference on “European policies, local strategies and future”, which will take place at the European Parliament

14/09/2018

BioBorrel in Amsterdam: Registration open until next week

The newest edition of BioBorrel will be held at Pakhuis de Zwijger in Amsterdam at 6 pm on 26th September 2018

03/09/2018

Bio Fach South East Asia: Successful premiere in Bangkok

In July, BioFach South East Asia at Impact Exhibition Center in Bangkok gathered international stakeholders from the organic sector for the first time

31/08/2018

GO! Organic Festival 8th - 9th september 2018 - London

From artisan breads to vegan wines, from speciality cheeses to organic sauces and soups, from superfood skincare to zero waste soaps – GO! Organic Festival will showcase the sumptuous diversity that lies at the heart of the organic and sustainability movement...

27/08/2018

Biofach China Closing Report

CLOSING REPORT June 2018 of Connature's Partner BioFach China

18/08/2018

Organic Food Iberia 2019: Major new organic trade fair in Madrid

The new trade show Organic Food Iberia will open at the IFEMA exhibition centre in Madrid in 2019.

13/08/2018

Connature Partner, Natural Products Scandinavia & the Nordic Organic Food Fair return to MalmöMässan

Preparations for Natural Products Scandinavia and the Nordic Organic Food Fair 2018 are now well underway, as the Nordic region’s biggest trade shows for natural and organic open its visitor registration for 2018

31/05/2014

Bhutan: Conference on organic and ecological agriculture a full success

From 5 - 8 March 2014, participants from 30 countries gathered in Bhutan at the IFOAM Conference on Organic and Ecological Agriculture in Mountain Ecosystems. The country created the vision of Gross National Happiness and made a visionary commitment to going 100% organic.

01/10/2012

Barcelona, Spain, from 25 to 26 October 2012.: Global Eco Forum 2012

The Euro-Mediterranean forum on sustainability, the Global Eco Forum, will take place in Barcelona, Spain, from 25 to 26 October 2012.

09/07/2012

25 - 29 october - Turin - Salone del Gusto and Terra Madre

For the first time, Salone del Gusto and Terra Madre merge to create a single event that will be held on 25 to 29 October 2012 in Turin, Italy

Press
18/02/2019

Organic market continues to grow everywere, in Europe as worldwide

In 2017, the European and international organic sector again recorded strong area and market growth

11/02/2019

Fair Trade demanded by cocoa producers

Bitter side of chocolate: "Breadline wages, poverty, child labour

01/02/2019

Organic farming wins performance comparison

German scientists have presented the most comprehensive study to date on the ecological and social performance of organic agriculture. The result is clear: Organic farming leads in five out of seven areas

18/01/2019

EU scientific advisors call for changing the genetic engineering law

The scientific advisors to the EU Commission have presented a paper in which they urge the Commission to change genetic engineering legislation

03/01/2019

Amazon expands network of organic supermarkets in the US

Amazon and the organic sector...expansion in the US

28/12/2018

New study on organic agriculture. Is it disadvantageous for the climate?

Organic agriculture is more damaging to the climate than conventional agriculture, scientists from Sweden and the USA claim. But is that true?

21/12/2018

Switzerland Organic sales: vegetables, fruit and milk increase significantly

From September 2017 to August 2018, 46,663 tonnes of organic vegetables worth 340 million euros were sold in Swiss retail outlets

10/12/2018

The integrity of the international organic market

After four years, the FiBL-project Consolidation of Organic Certification Bodies ended successfully

03/12/2018

EU slam for inspection body certification in Kenya

The EU Commission has examined the branch of an international certifier in Kenya and issued a very poor certificate for its work. So far, however, it has only had to do a little detention

19/11/2018

Switzerland: Organic sales of veggies, fruit and milk have increased significantly

From September 2017 to August 2018, 46,663 tonnes of organic vegetables worth 340 million euros were sold in Swiss retail outlets

09/11/2018

EU organic control in Romania slowly improving

The report praises Romania's efforts to improve the monitoring of organic inspection posts

06/11/2018

New study: Eating organic food reduces cancer risk

French scientists investigated the link between the consumption of organic food and the risk of developing certain types of cancer

02/11/2018

Germany: Microplastic in food worries consumers

Microplastic has so far been found mainly in marine fish. They confuse microplastic particles with plankton...

26/10/2018

Critical look at new additives

Again and again, individual countries move for the inclusion of further additives in the EU Organic Regulation (Annex VIII) and thus for allowing them

22/10/2018

FiBL: SMART Tool to assess food chains

In Switzerland, the Fair Food Initiative failed in a referendum. It wanted to oblige the government to strengthen “the supply of food that is of good quality...

12/10/2018

Natural cosmetics as a future market

The cosmetics market is very dynamic and a lot has happened in the last twelve months. This was emphasised by Elfriede Dambacher, consultant and expert in the natural cosmetics industry, at the 11th Natural Cosmetics Conference​

01/10/2018

German organic market: upward trend continues

What does the sales barometer for organic shops in Germany look like in the second quarter of 2018?  The turnover of the shops surveyed continues to rise

26/09/2018

Austria: Conversion to organic farming without regrets

According to a survey by Keyquest among 500 respondents, 98% of Austrian organic farmers would decide to switch back to organic farming again

20/09/2018

Switzerland: Organic consumption has doubled in ten years

In 2017, organic products worth 2.7 bn Swiss francs were sold in Switzerland, equivalent to 2.4 bn euros or 284 euros per capita

17/09/2018

Sustainability bank Triodos invests in crowdfunding platform

Bettervest specializes in renewable energy and energy efficiency projects that seek to raise money from the crowd through the platform

14/09/2018

Austria: denn‘s biomarkt expands branch network

A new denn's organic market store will open in Eisenstadt, Austria

03/09/2018

E.V.I - the document on Sustainability which wins the trust of Investors

Companies and start-up need to consider sustainability when it comes to plan processes, products, governance and promotion

28/08/2018

Italy: Organic sector shows impressive growth

Market data collected by Nielsen market research until May 2018, confirm a very positive trend in the Italian organic sector

27/08/2018

Canada Organic Trade Association welcomes government funding for organic sector

According to the Canada Organic Trade Association (COTA), the Canadian government is investing $8.3 million in organic agriculture research

22/08/2018

Nestlé USA: Misleading Non-GMO seal

By filing a lawsuit against Nestlé, a woman from California alleged that the US company misleads consumers by using its ‘No GMO ingredients’ seal as it might easily be confused with the Non-GMO Project Verified Seal, reports CBS News

18/08/2018

Core Organic: Europe-wide research for organic farming continues

European research into organic farming is being continued with the Core Organic Cofund programme

09/08/2018

RELACS EU: Project website launched

The EU-project which will be run by FiBL Switzerland as well as IFOAM EU aims at fostering the development and facilitating the adoption of cost-efficient and environmentally safe tools and technologies...

08/01/2016

Organic groceries discount at Walmart Canada

Walmart Canada has quietly launched a new lineup of organic products under its Great Value store brand

18/02/2019

Organic market continues to grow everywere, in Europe as worldwide

In 2017, the European and international organic sector again recorded strong area and market growth

11/02/2019

Fair Trade demanded by cocoa producers

Bitter side of chocolate: "Breadline wages, poverty, child labour

01/02/2019

Organic farming wins performance comparison

German scientists have presented the most comprehensive study to date on the ecological and social performance of organic agriculture. The result is clear: Organic farming leads in five out of seven areas

18/01/2019

EU scientific advisors call for changing the genetic engineering law

The scientific advisors to the EU Commission have presented a paper in which they urge the Commission to change genetic engineering legislation

03/01/2019

Amazon expands network of organic supermarkets in the US

Amazon and the organic sector...expansion in the US

28/12/2018

New study on organic agriculture. Is it disadvantageous for the climate?

Organic agriculture is more damaging to the climate than conventional agriculture, scientists from Sweden and the USA claim. But is that true?

21/12/2018

Switzerland Organic sales: vegetables, fruit and milk increase significantly

From September 2017 to August 2018, 46,663 tonnes of organic vegetables worth 340 million euros were sold in Swiss retail outlets

10/12/2018

The integrity of the international organic market

After four years, the FiBL-project Consolidation of Organic Certification Bodies ended successfully

03/12/2018

EU slam for inspection body certification in Kenya

The EU Commission has examined the branch of an international certifier in Kenya and issued a very poor certificate for its work. So far, however, it has only had to do a little detention

19/11/2018

Switzerland: Organic sales of veggies, fruit and milk have increased significantly

From September 2017 to August 2018, 46,663 tonnes of organic vegetables worth 340 million euros were sold in Swiss retail outlets

09/11/2018

EU organic control in Romania slowly improving

The report praises Romania's efforts to improve the monitoring of organic inspection posts

06/11/2018

New study: Eating organic food reduces cancer risk

French scientists investigated the link between the consumption of organic food and the risk of developing certain types of cancer

02/11/2018

Germany: Microplastic in food worries consumers

Microplastic has so far been found mainly in marine fish. They confuse microplastic particles with plankton...

26/10/2018

Critical look at new additives

Again and again, individual countries move for the inclusion of further additives in the EU Organic Regulation (Annex VIII) and thus for allowing them

22/10/2018

FiBL: SMART Tool to assess food chains

In Switzerland, the Fair Food Initiative failed in a referendum. It wanted to oblige the government to strengthen “the supply of food that is of good quality...

12/10/2018

Natural cosmetics as a future market

The cosmetics market is very dynamic and a lot has happened in the last twelve months. This was emphasised by Elfriede Dambacher, consultant and expert in the natural cosmetics industry, at the 11th Natural Cosmetics Conference​

01/10/2018

German organic market: upward trend continues

What does the sales barometer for organic shops in Germany look like in the second quarter of 2018?  The turnover of the shops surveyed continues to rise

26/09/2018

Austria: Conversion to organic farming without regrets

According to a survey by Keyquest among 500 respondents, 98% of Austrian organic farmers would decide to switch back to organic farming again

20/09/2018

Switzerland: Organic consumption has doubled in ten years

In 2017, organic products worth 2.7 bn Swiss francs were sold in Switzerland, equivalent to 2.4 bn euros or 284 euros per capita

17/09/2018

Sustainability bank Triodos invests in crowdfunding platform

Bettervest specializes in renewable energy and energy efficiency projects that seek to raise money from the crowd through the platform

14/09/2018

Austria: denn‘s biomarkt expands branch network

A new denn's organic market store will open in Eisenstadt, Austria

03/09/2018

E.V.I - the document on Sustainability which wins the trust of Investors

Companies and start-up need to consider sustainability when it comes to plan processes, products, governance and promotion

28/08/2018

Italy: Organic sector shows impressive growth

Market data collected by Nielsen market research until May 2018, confirm a very positive trend in the Italian organic sector

27/08/2018

Canada Organic Trade Association welcomes government funding for organic sector

According to the Canada Organic Trade Association (COTA), the Canadian government is investing $8.3 million in organic agriculture research

22/08/2018

Nestlé USA: Misleading Non-GMO seal

By filing a lawsuit against Nestlé, a woman from California alleged that the US company misleads consumers by using its ‘No GMO ingredients’ seal as it might easily be confused with the Non-GMO Project Verified Seal, reports CBS News

18/08/2018

Core Organic: Europe-wide research for organic farming continues

European research into organic farming is being continued with the Core Organic Cofund programme

09/08/2018

RELACS EU: Project website launched

The EU-project which will be run by FiBL Switzerland as well as IFOAM EU aims at fostering the development and facilitating the adoption of cost-efficient and environmentally safe tools and technologies...

08/01/2016

Organic groceries discount at Walmart Canada

Walmart Canada has quietly launched a new lineup of organic products under its Great Value store brand